The Tale of Melon City - Master Notes

I. The Just and Placid King

The King is described as "just and placid." He orders an arch to be built across the thoroughfare to "edify" spectators. However, the arch is built too low, and it knocks off the king's crown as he rides under it.

II. The Chain of Blame

To uphold justice, the King orders a hanging. A comical blame game ensues:

Chief Builders → Workmen → Masons → Architect → The King (who amended the plans)

The Architect cleverley points out that the King himself had made changes to the blueprints, making the King the ultimate culprit.

III. The Absurd Justice

The King, confused, calls for the Wisest Man (who is so old he can't see). The wise man suggests hanging the Arch because "it was the arch that hit the king." A minister objects, saying you can't hang something that touched the King's head.

The Solution: The crowd is restless. The ministers decide that "someone" must be hanged. They set up a noose, and only the King is tall enough to fit it. Thus, the King is hanged by his own decree.

IV. Long Live the Melon!

According to custom, the next person to pass the City Gate chooses the king. An idiot passes by, and since he loves melons, he says "A Melon." A melon is literally crowned king. The people are happy because the melon king does not interfere with their lives (Laissez-faire).

V. Satirical Message

Bureaucratic Folly: Moving blame instead of taking responsibility.
Public Apathy: The crowd just wants a spectacle (the hanging) regardless of who is guilty.
Governance: A critique of "blind" justice that follows the letter of the law but ignores the spirit.

"Under the arch he lost his crown.
The arch was built too low. A frown
Appeared upon his placid face."

[Q] Why was the King's "placid" face replaced by a frown?

Reason:

The King's Ego and Dignity were hurt. He wanted the arch to "edify" (impress) people, but instead, it made him look ridiculous by knocking his crown off. This minor inconvenience led him to order an immediate execution, showing how fragile his "placidity" actually was.

"‘Let us postpone consideration Of finer points like guilt. The nation Wants a hanging.’"

[Q] What does this show about the King's sense of justice?

The Satire:

The King values Public Satisfaction over actual justice. He realizes the crowd is becoming restless and dangerous. Instead of finding the truly guilty person, he decides that "anybody" will do, as long as a hanging take place. This is a critique of populism.

[Q] How did the Architect defend himself?

Defense:

He used the King's own vanity against him. He reminded the King that he had Amended the Plans mid-way. By the law of the land, if the King changed the design, the King was technically responsible for the flaw. This cornered the King into his own logic.

[Q] What was the criteria for the final hanging?

Criteria:

The ministers set up a noose and declared that Physical Height was the only criteria for guilt. Whoever was tall enough to reach the noose would be hanged. Ironically, only the King was tall enough, making his own stature the reason for his death.

[Q] Why were the people happy with a "Melon" as their King?

Conclusion:

The people wanted Laissez-faire (Non-interference). As long as the king (a melon) didn't tax them, start wars, or interfere in their businesses, they didn't care who sat on the throne. It satirizes the lack of political awareness in the general public.

[Q6] Who chose the new king?

An idiot who passed by the gate.

[Q7] The author of the poem?

Vikram Seth.

Melon City - Glossary & Facts

Satirical Glossary

The Tale of Melon City

Placid: Calm and peaceful, with little movement or activity.

Triumphally: In a way that celebrates a great victory or success.

Edify: To instruct or improve someone morally or intellectually.

Gallows: A wooden frame, consisting of a crossbeam on two upright posts, on which criminals are hanged.

Guilt: The fact of having committed a specified or implied offence or crime.

Amend: Make minor changes in order to make it fairer.

Heralds: An official messenger bringing news.

Reverently: With deep and solemn respect.

Laissez Faire: Policy of non-interference by the government in people's lives.

Irony: The expression of meaning through language that normally signifies the opposite.

Satire: Use of humor to expose people's stupidity or vices.

The arch was built to Span the major thoroughfare.

The Wisest Man was so old that he was senile.

The city name was changed to Melon City to honor the new king.

📱 Practice MCQs for this topic inside our App

The Tale of Melon City

Extract Qs - The Crown & The Noose

Satirical Glossary